Blog

Notes from building execution infrastructure.

Prop-firm drawdown arithmetic, broker symbol suffixes, contract rolls, and what actually breaks when you copy a trade across five platforms.

All posts

Copying Telegram and Discord Signals to a Futures Account

A signal written for a forex broker says 'BUY GOLD 0.35 lots'. A futures account has no lots, no GOLD, and no fractional contracts. Three translations have to happen before that message becomes a position, and each one can quietly change the trade.

A signal lands in a Telegram channel at 09:32. It says: BUY GOLD, entry 3,412, stop 3,396, TP1 3,428, TP2 3,450, risk 0.35 lots. On a MetaTrader account that message is almost self-executing. On a Tradovate futures account, not one field in it is directly usable. There is no instrument called GOLD. There is no such thing as 0.35 of a contract. And the price 3,412 is not the price the futures contract is trading at.

Yes, you can copy a Telegram or Discord signal to a futures account, and the setup is not exotic. What it requires is three translations, done in the right order: the instrument has to become a specific contract, the size has to become a whole number of contracts, and the stop and target have to survive the fact that the two markets do not quote the same price. Get any of the three wrong and the trade still executes — just not the trade you were sent.

Check your firm allows a copier before anything else

A prop-firm account on Tradovate, at the evaluation, funded or live stage, is a simulated account, so it connects without Tradovate's paid API access. Whether you may pipe a signal channel into it is your firm's decision: read its rules on trade copiers for the stage you are at before you buy the challenge. A personal live Tradovate account needs Tradovate's API access, which Tradovate offers when you sign in.

Everything below assumes an account your firm lets you copy into.

Translation one: from an instrument name to a contract

Futures instruments are not names, they are dated contracts. MES is not one thing you trade; MESZ6 is December 2026 micro S&P, MESH7 is March 2027, and they trade at different prices at the same moment. A signal that says GOLD has to become a root and a month before anything can happen.

The mapping rules that do this are short lines you write once per destination. The forms worth knowing:

RuleWhat it does
no rule, futures providerthe Follower trades the same contract as the Provider
~ES=MES~any ES month trades MES in the same month, at the built-in ratio
~ES=MES*5~the same substitution at a ratio you set
~ES=MESH7~pinned to one specific contract month
~US500=MES~a CFD or signal name resolves to the front month, re-checked hourly
~ES=US500*5~the reverse direction, futures to a CFD name

The row that matters most for signal copying is the fifth. A Telegram channel writes in CFD vocabulary — GOLD, US500, NAS100, EURUSD — because that is what its audience trades. A rule mapping that name to a futures root gets you the front month automatically, and it is re-resolved on a schedule, which stops the mapping pointing at an expired contract eight weeks later.

Write the mapping before you turn the channel on, not after the first trade. A signal for an unmapped instrument is not guessed at — it is skipped, with "no contract mapping" as the reason.

Translation two: from lots to whole contracts

This translation surprises people, because it changes the risk rather than the instrument.

Forex and CFD sizing is effectively continuous: 0.35 lots, or 0.07, or 1.62. Futures sizing is not. You trade one contract, or two, or none. There is no partial position, so rounding is not a cosmetic step.

This is what the micro contracts are for. A worked, illustrative example on gold:

text
signal risk          0.5% of a 25,000 account          = 125.00
stop distance        16 points on gold

GC  (full)           100 oz per contract, 100 per pt   → 0.078 contracts → 0
MGC (micro)           10 oz per contract,  10 per pt   → 0.781 contracts → 0
                     at 1 contract the risk is 160.00  = 0.64% of the account

On a 25,000 dollar account with a tight stop, even the micro is too large. That is not a flaw in the copier; it is the market telling you the minimum position size exceeds your intended risk. Two responses are legitimate, and one is not.

  • Skip the trade and log it. Correct by default. An account that cannot take a trade at the risk you specified should not take it at a different risk.
  • Accept a documented overshoot on specific instruments. Defensible if you decided it in advance and wrote the number down.
  • Silently round up to one contract. Not defensible. This is how a 0.5 per cent strategy becomes a 0.64 per cent strategy without anyone deciding that it should.

The built-in micro-to-mini ratios the copier already knows are worth having in front of you when you are choosing which root to map to:

MiniMicroMicros per mini
ESMES10
NQMNQ10
YMMYM10
RTYM2K10
GCMGC10
CLMCL10
SISIL5
6EM6E10
BTCMBT50

Ten to one is the common case on index and metal contracts, and it decides whether a signal is takeable on a 25,000 account.

Translation three: the stop, the target and the ladder

Here the honest answer differs from the intuitive one.

A signal's stop and target are prices on the provider's market. Across CFD and futures those markets do not quote the same number for the same underlying, because a futures contract carries financing and time to expiry that a spot CFD does not. Copying the literal price 3,396 onto a futures account puts a stop at a level that means something different, and sometimes at one already through the market.

Here is what the copier actually does with them: the signal's stop and target go onto the futures position as its bracket, at the prices the message gives, placed at the broker straight after the entry fills. Two checks run first. A level on the wrong side of the entry refuses the trade, and so does a level more than ten per cent away from the futures contract's own quote, which catches a misread number or a call reposted from days ago. Neither check translates a CFD price into a futures one. The basis between the two is usually far smaller than ten per cent, so a stop quoted in CFD terms is placed at that literal number on the contract.

That has one implication to hear before you configure anything: follow a channel that quotes CFD prices on a futures account and every bracket sits a basis away from where the channel meant it, and the size is worked out from the futures contract's live price to that shifted stop. Check the gap between the two quotes on each instrument you map before you turn the channel on. If you set a slippage limit, it measures the futures quote against the channel's entry, so the same gap can count as slippage and stop the trade being placed.

Multiple targets become a scale-out ladder. TP1, TP2, TP3 in a signal is not three targets on one position; it is a plan to close a third at each. On a futures account this runs straight into whole-number sizing again: a one-contract position cannot be scaled out in thirds. Either the position is large enough in micros for the ladder to be meaningful — three contracts, one rung each — or the ladder collapses to a single exit and you should decide which rung it is.

Rollover: the trade that outlives its contract

Futures contracts expire. A December contract stops trading; the volume moves to March. If your mapping points at the front month, it moves too, and it does so while you may have a position open.

Two rules keep this uneventful.

Know your contract's last trading day before you open the position. It is a calendar fact published by the exchange, and ignoring it is the most common way a futures newcomer ends up somewhere they did not expect.

Do not expect a copier to roll a position for you. Rolling means closing one contract and opening another at a different price — a new trade with a new basis and a new cost, which makes it a trading decision. A mapping rule that re-resolves to the new front month changes which contract the next signal trades; it does not touch the position you hold.

Netting: one position per contract

The last structural difference. Most futures accounts net: buy two ES and sell one and you hold one long, not a long two and a short one side by side as MetaTrader hedging accounts allow.

Three consequences for signal copying:

  • Two channels on the same instrument will interfere. Channel A's long and channel B's short do not coexist; they offset. Map them to different roots or different accounts, or accept the netting.
  • A close instruction closes a share of a netted position, not a specific earlier trade. There is no ticket to close.
  • Opposite signals are a flatten, not a hedge. If your plan relied on holding both sides, a netting account will not do it.

Frequently asked questions

Can I copy a Telegram signal to a futures account?

Yes, with three things configured: a mapping rule that turns the signal's instrument name into a futures root, whole-number sizing with a rule for what happens when the computed size rounds below one contract, and a check on the stop and target. The signal's own levels are placed with the futures order as its bracket, at the prices the message gives, so a channel that quotes CFD prices needs the basis checked first.

How does a copier know which futures contract month to trade?

From the mapping rule. A rule can pin one month explicitly, carry the Provider's month across to a different root, or resolve to the front month and re-check that on a schedule so it follows the roll. Front-month resolution is the right choice for signals written in CFD vocabulary, because those signals carry no month information at all.

What happens if the signal size is smaller than one contract?

The trade is skipped and logged with the reason, rather than rounded up. Rounding up on a tight stop can be a large multiple of the intended risk, which is why the default is to decline. Mapping to the micro contract instead of the mini — ten times smaller on most index and metal roots — is usually what makes small-account sizing viable.

Do futures accounts support multiple take-profit levels from a signal?

Only where the position is big enough to divide. Three rungs need at least three contracts, because there is no fractional contract to close. On a one-contract position the ladder is not a ladder, and it is better to choose a single exit deliberately than to discover which rung the system picked.

Is my futures position protected if the channel goes quiet?

As far as the signal's own levels go, yes. Its stop and target are placed at the broker as a bracket straight after the entry fills, so they work whether or not the channel posts again and whether or not the relay is reachable. A later "close" or "move the stop" message is applied when it arrives. What the bracket cannot do is correct a level quoted in CFD prices, which is why the basis is worth checking before you map a CFD channel to futures.

Can I copy signals into a futures prop firm or evaluation account?

Yes, where your firm allows trade copiers. A prop-firm account on Tradovate is simulated, so it connects without Tradovate's paid API access; a personal live account needs Tradovate's API access, which Tradovate offers when you sign in. Check your firm's rules on copying for the stage you are at before you buy a challenge you intend to automate.

Where this fits

If you are still deciding whether you need a signal copier or a trade copier — two different machines that get confused constantly — our piece on trade copiers versus signal copiers separates them properly. And the reason a stop price cannot simply be copied from a CFD to a futures contract is the whole subject of our explainer on CFD and futures prices.


Trading involves risk and you can lose money. Nothing here is financial advice.